Kid in puffy winter jacket
At Every Turn > Primary Care > Winter weather advisory: Why car seats and puffy coats are an unsafe mix
Tips Nov 06, 2024

Winter weather advisory: Why car seats and puffy coats are an unsafe mix

Anika Nelson, MD, Pediatrician Nov 06, 2024 3 minute read

If you’ve ever seen the holiday classic “A Christmas Story,” you’ll know exactly what iconic scene I’m talking about. It’s a freezing winter morning and the mom is getting the boys ready to go to school. She’s struggling to cram the younger brother, Randy, into an enormous red wool snow suit. Once finally buttoned up, she tops it off with two hats and a scarf that leaves only a tiny crack for his eyes.

“I can’t put my arms down,” Randy screams while older brother, Ralphie, comments that he looks like a tick about to pop.

I must have seen that movie a hundred times and I still laugh every time I see that scene. However, while it is hilarious, it raises an important safety issue when it comes to kids and winter clothing.

Winter coats affect how your child is secured in their car seat

When those winter winds blow, it’s natural for parents to want to bundle their kids up before heading out. And that’s totally fine if you’re playing outside, sledding, building a snowman or going for a walk. But if you’re driving anywhere, it’s important to keep in mind that puffy winter coats affect how your child is secured in their car seat.

The extra padding of a bulky coat makes it impossible to get the harness properly snug. Even though it might feel like the harness is snug, in a crash the extra material will compress, making the harness too loose to be effective. Loose harness straps on a car seat drastically increase the chance that your child could be injured in the event of a collision.

If you’re skeptical, I encourage you to test it out. Put your child in their winter coat, buckle them into their car seat and tighten down the straps. Then unbuckle them, remove their jacket, and re-buckle them into the car seat without adjusting the straps. You’ll be shocked how loose the straps actually are. 

What are parents supposed to do?

So, you’re probably thinking, what am I supposed to do? It’s winter in Wisconsin. The temperatures are hovering around the single digits and I don’t want my kid to freeze.

  • When getting ready to use a car seat in the winter, dress your child in thin, warm layers such as fleece or Thinsulate.

  • For rear-facing babies in an infant seat, once the child is secure in the seat, put a warm blanket over them (it’s best to keep this blanket in the house when not in use so it’s not sitting in a freezing car all day or night).

  • For older, rear-facing toddlers or for forward-facing children, once the child is snug in the harness you can put their coat on backward over their arms and shoulders to keep them warm until the car’s heater kicks in.

  • Remember, hats, mittens and even snow pants can help keep kids quite cozy even without their coat. That's what I do with my kids when we're bundled up to go sledding or snowboarding.

I understand the thought of having to go through this each time you get in and out of the car is daunting, especially as you’re trying to keep yourself warm as well. But it really is important, even if you’re just going for a quick jaunt around the neighborhood. Studies have shown that most crashes occur within 20 minutes or less from home and at relatively slow speeds. Motor vehicle crashes, wherever they occur, are the second leading cause of death in children older than 1.

Car seat safety guidelines

Before you drive away, make sure to follow these car seat safety guidelines:

  • The chest clip should always be at armpit level.

  • The harness should fit snugly against the child without any twist. You shouldn’t be able to pinch any slack in the harness at the shoulder.

  • For rear-facing seats, the harness height should be at or below the top of the child’s shoulder.

  • For forward-facing seats, the harness height should be at or above the top of the child’s shoulder.

Did you know, Children's Wisconsin has a comprehensive car seat program and is a statewide leader in child passenger safety? It’s true. If you have any concerns about your car or booster seat installation, you can schedule a free appointment with the Children’s Wisconsin Car Seat Clinic by calling (414) 607-5280 or visiting our website

Children's Wisconsin Resources

Children’s Wisconsin has more than 20 primary care offices conveniently located throughout the Milwaukee area and southeast Wisconsin. Find a pediatrician near you. View more articles from Anika Nelson, MD

Related Stories

Antibiotic overuse and resistance Children's Wisconsin
Tips Nov 20, 2024

Why antibiotics aren't always the answer

Katie Ray, PharmD Pharmacist

Antibiotics are one of the most commonly prescribed medications for children in the United States.

Healthy and happy Thanksgiving Children's Wisconsin
Tips Nov 07, 2024

Living mindfully during Thanksgiving and the holidays

Jean Cornell, MD Pediatrician

Activities and mindfulness will help you and your kids be your best selves during the holiday season.

Are your kids ready for a sleepover Children's Wisconsin
Tips Nov 01, 2024

How to tell if your child is ready for a sleepover

Lori Albright, MD Pediatrician

Sleepovers can be exciting for many children, but ensuring your child is emotionally and socially ready for the experience is essential.

Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) Children's Wisconsin Center for Child Development
Tips Oct 30, 2024

Understanding ADHD

Erin Long, PhD Clinical Psychologist

About one in nine children in the United States is now diagnosed with ADHD, adding up to more than 7 million kids.

Vitamins and probiotics and kids Children's Wisconsin
Tips Oct 14, 2024

The ABCs of vitamins, minerals and probiotics

Matthew Maves, MD Pediatrician

Simplifying the complexities of vitamins and minerals so you can make informed choices for your child.

Debunking viral season myths Children's Wisconsin
Tips Oct 09, 2024

The facts and fictions of cold and flu season

Bradley Julga, MD Pediatrician

Busting six common viral season myths and setting the record straight.