Antibiotic overuse and resistance Children's Wisconsin
At Every Turn > Primary Care > Why antibiotics aren't always the answer
Tips Nov 20, 2024

Why antibiotics aren't always the answer

Katie Ray, PharmD, Pharmacist 5 minute read

Every parent has been there. Your child starts to complain of a sore throat. You check their forehead — definitely warm. Oh no, not strep throat again. When you call the pediatrician’s office, the nurse practitioner tells you to bring them in for a strep test. But last year they had the same thing, you say, and they took antibiotics and got better. Couldn’t they just call in a prescription over the phone?

Yes, that would certainly be easier. But it wouldn’t be better. In this case, without doing a strep test, there is no way to know if that sore throat needs antibiotics. And it’s best to avoid giving your child an antibiotic unless they truly need it.

Many antibiotics are unnecessary

Antibiotics remain one of the most commonly prescribed medications for children in the United States. Roughly 1 in 30 children has had an antibiotic in the past month, and that rate is higher for the youngest kids. However, up to half of antibiotic prescriptions are unnecessary. Why does this occur, and why is it a problem?

Antibiotics help fight bacterial infections

Fever usually indicates an infection, which can be caused by two main types of microbes (“germs”): viruses and bacteria. Antibiotics do not kill viruses, as the body fights these off on its own. However, antibiotics can help the body fight off bacterial infections, so it is appropriate to take them in those cases.

Most infections are viral

The fact is that the large majority of infections in children are viral, which means that most do not need an antibiotic. Unfortunately, it can be hard to tell which germ is responsible. Some kinds of infections, such as colds (also called “upper respiratory infections”) are almost always caused by a virus. Others, like urinary infections, are almost always bacterial. But many common ones, like sore throats, ear infections and pneumonia, can be caused by either. Sometimes a test can be done, such as strep test for sore throat. (Strep is a bacteria, so it is treated with antibiotics.) In other cases, there are clues from the history and physical exam that can help determine which it is. And sometimes, quite frankly, it’s a bit of a guess.

{A9A46357-E630-4BC7-9DA6-C8F08ECB93B8}

Problems with unnecessary use

You might be asking, “Hey, if you can’t be sure, why not just be on the safe side and take an antibiotic?” Well, aside from being a waste of money, there are definite problems with unnecessary antibiotic use. Here are a few:

  • When you take antibiotics, it also affects the bacteria that normally live in and on our bodies. A common side effect is diarrhea due to the antibiotics killing these good bacteria that live in our intestines and help digest food.

  • When bacteria are exposed to antibiotics, some of them are not killed, because they are resistant to the effect of the medication. These resistant germs can spread, and when they cause infections they are harder to treat, requiring stronger and more expensive antibiotics. One such “superbug” that has become very common is called MRSA, which causes abscesses and other serious infections, and can be difficult to treat because of its resistance to commonly used antibiotics.

  • Many viral infections can cause a rash. It can be impossible to tell if the rash is an allergy to the medication, or one that would have developed anyway because of the virus. We might suspect the child is allergic, meaning we may have to avoid that medication in the future. The next time the child truly needs an antibiotic, it may be harder to choose one that will work.

  • There may be long-term effects. Recent studies have shown that antibiotic use in young children can increase the risk of asthma later in life, and other studies have linked early antibiotics to obesity.

Ask questions

What can you do to avoid unnecessary antibiotics for your child? Here are a few questions you can ask your health care provider if they prescribe an antibiotic for your child:

  • What infection is the antibiotic for? How sure are you that it’s a bacterial infection?

  • Is it okay to wait a few days to see if the antibiotic is necessary? (This is one of the recommendations from the American Academy of Pediatrics for ear infections, for example.)

  • If an antibiotic is needed, is this the “narrowest spectrum” antibiotic we can use? Antibiotics typically kill a variety of different bacteria. Narrow-spectrum antibiotics kill only a few types, while broad-spectrum antibiotics kill many types. It is always best to pick the one that will kill the fewest types but still take care of the infection. Narrow-spectrum antibiotics tend to cause fewer side effects and are usually less expensive. For most children with bacterial respiratory and skin infections, narrow spectrum antibiotics are suitable.

Parents and health care providers always want what’s best for the child. But in some cases, it’s not so simple. As always, if you ever have any questions or concerns about your child’s health, reach out to their pediatrician. 

Children's Wisconsin Resources

Children’s Wisconsin has more than 20 primary care offices conveniently located throughout the Milwaukee area and southeast Wisconsin. Find a pediatrician near you. View more articles from Katie Ray, PharmD

Related stories

What Are Obesogens and Do They Cause Weight Gain in Children? Children's Wisconsin
Tips Apr 16, 2025

Are Obesogens Causing Weight Gain in Children?

Pallavi Iyer, MD Endocrinologist

Obesity rates have more than tripled since the 1960s for both adults and children — but why?

Measles outbreak United States 2025 Children's Wisconsin
Tips Apr 16, 2025

Measles Outbreak Shows Importance of Getting Your Kids Vaccinated

Frank Zhu, MD Medical Director

The recent measles outbreak is a regrettable reminder to all of us of just how preventable this disease truly is when your child is vaccinated.

Beige parenting Children's Wisconsin
Tips Apr 02, 2025

The Rainbow Connection: How the Beige Parenting Trend Can Affect Children

Elizabeth Frantal, PA-C Physician Assistant

Beige parenting deviates from the bright colors and bold patterns that have dominated baby items for decades.

Children's Wisconsin Eating Disorder Program Adolescent Health and Medicine
Tips Mar 26, 2025

What Parents Need To Know About the Rise in Eating Disorders

Margaret Thew, DNP, FNP-BC Family Nurse Practitioner

Eating disorders can affect many parts of a child’s life, including how they feel physically and emotionally, as well as their friendships.

How to treat seasonal allergies in kids Children's Wisconsin
Tips Mar 21, 2025

Kids and Seasonal Allergies: Navigating Symptoms and Solutions

Andrew MacGinnitie, MD Allergy Immunology Specialist

Knowing what’s causing your child’s seasonal allergies can be helpful in minimizing exposure to common triggers.

Is your kid ready for overnight summer camp Children's Wisconsin
Tips Mar 18, 2025

Happy Campers: How To Tell if Your Child Is Ready for Overnight Camp

Maggie Moegenburg, LCSW Behavioral Health Consultant

If you’re thinking about sending your child to an overnight camp, it’s essential to assess whether they’re ready.

Teaching kids about finances and money management Children's Wisconsin
Tips Mar 04, 2025

Dollars and Sense: Teaching Kids About Money

Sadia Hussain, DO Pediatrician

How to build healthy attitudes and practices about money.