Woman Grocery Shopping with Daughter
At Every Turn > Nutrition and Exercise > Why new food labels will help in some ways, but not others
Tips Mar 31, 2014

Why new food labels will help in some ways, but not others

Amber Carbajal, MBA, RD, CD, Clinical Nutrition Manager Mar 31, 2014

You may or may not read the labels on the foods you eat. Regardless, the Nutrition Facts label could have some big changes ahead that will make reading it a bit easier — for some people.

What are the changes?

First lady Michelle Obama is partnering with the FDA to make several label changes to combat our rising obesity epidemic. The changes include:

  • Putting calories front and center and in large type to put a greater focus on calorie content
  • Including “added sugars” on the label to help consumers differentiate between naturally occurring sugars and the empty calories of added ones
  • Emphasizing different nutrients (Vitamin D and potassium instead of Vitamins C and A
  • Eliminating the “Calories from Fat” label
  • Shifting the “% Daily Value” (%DV) from the right to left column
  • Changing the serving size reference amounts to reflect common current consumption

Nutrition Labels

A dietitian’s opinion

As a dietitian, I see a lot of patients who don’t pay attention to food labels and find them confusing. I try to be very mindful of the information I give to patients so that it makes sense and gives them direction to take the next step with their health. While I see some benefits to these changes, I also have concerns.

On the positive side, putting calories and number of servings per container in a larger type is a great idea! Hopefully, it will encourage people to actually look at the label and maybe rethink what they eat. I also agree with the idea of taking away “Calories from Fat” on the label — this just hasn’t been a very helpful reference for most of us.

My concerns, however, stem from the new placement of the Percent Daily Value (%DV), and the changing of the Serving Size reference amounts. Many people get confused by %DV and what it means, so probably the best thing to know is that %DV is based on a 2,000-calorie diet. Not everybody needs 2,000 calories per day for a healthy diet, however, so these numbers don’t always apply. Placing the %DV in the first column gives it too much importance.

My tip: When you look at a label, focus on the actual gram amounts of nutrients that are important for your own personal health, whether that’s fiber, fat, cholesterol or some other nutrient.

The impact of changing serving sizes

But the biggest worry I have is about the change in serving sizes. The FDA states that serving size reference amounts should be updated from previous standards to “reflect how much people typically eat at one time.” But wait a minute, aren’t we trying to combat an obesity epidemic? Look up “bagel serving size” on Google Images and you’ll see what a standard bagel looked like 20 years ago and what’s considered normal nowadays. It’s nearly twice as large and more than double the calories! People will think that the larger serving sizes are what they “should” be eating and could eat even more. Why would we change serving sizes on the food label to make the larger amounts more acceptable?

The food label has never been a perfect tool to help us make decisions about what we do or don’t eat. It has always required some extra knowledge or education about how to use it best for our own individual health goals. I think the new food label may help in some ways, but still won’t be a great tool for everyone. My advice (no surprise) is to consult with a dietitian if you have questions specific to your own health and reading food labels.

Amber Carbajal, MBA, RD, CD Amber Carbajal, MBA, RD, CD Clinical Nutrition Manager Children’s Wisconsin
Children's Wisconsin knows that a nutritious diet and active lifestyle have a major impact on the health and well-being of children. 

 

 

View more articles from Amber Carbajal, MBA, RD, CD

Related stories

Autism Spectrum Disorder Children's Wisconsin Center for Child Development
Tips Jan 29, 2025

Understanding the Autism Spectrum

Erin Long, PhD Clinical Psychologist

Autism is an extremely diverse spectrum, and every person is different in terms of their strengths, challenges and interests.

Picky Eaters, Selective eating, ARFID Children's Wisconsin
Tips Jan 22, 2025

Food Fuss: When Picky Eating Is Something More Serious

Meghan Wall, PhD Pediatric Psychologist

Many children are picky eaters, but sometimes what seems like pickiness could be something more complex.

What Parents Need To Know About the Red Dye No. 3 Ban Children’s Wisconsin
Tips Jan 16, 2025

What Parents Need To Know About the Red Dye No. 3 Ban

Becky Plier, RD, CNSC Clinical Dietitian

The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has banned the use of red dye no. 3 in any food and drugs.

Working moms and breastfeeding Children's Wisconsin
Tips Jan 14, 2025

Working Moms: What’s Your Plan To Continue Breastfeeding?

Jessica Schilz, RN, IBCLC Lactation Consultant

Workplaces are now more supportive of breastfeeding than ever.

Top concerns for breastfeeding moms Children's Wisconsin
Tips Jan 08, 2025

Top 4 Breastfeeding Concerns and How To Address Them

Jessica Schilz, RN, IBCLC Lactation Consultant

As natural as breastfeeding is, it does not always come easily to a new mom or baby.

Caring for asthma in winter Children's Wisconsin
Tips Dec 18, 2024

Fresh Breath: How To Manage Asthma During the Winter

Michelle Hwang, MD Pediatrician

The dry, cold weather can lead to an increase in asthma attacks.

Holiday safety Children's Wisconsin
Tips Dec 13, 2024

Tis the Season: How To Make Your Holidays Festive and Safe

Patrick Lehman, MD Pediatrician

Tips to help prepare for potential dangers of the holidays.